PEM vs Alkaline electrolyzers

PEM or Alkaline?
Evaluating what is the best option is always difficult

PEM (Proton Exchange Membrane) electrolysis and alkaline electrolysis are both methods of using electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen gases. However, they differ in the type of electrolyte solution that is used and the kind of membrane that separates the anode and cathode.

In PEM electrolysis, a proton exchange membrane is used to separate the anode and cathode. The electrolyte solution is an acidic one, typically made up of a dilute solution of sulfuric acid. The PEM acts as an ion conductor, allowing protons (H+) to pass through it from the anode to the cathode while preventing the mixing of the hydrogen and oxygen gases that are produced at the electrodes. PEM electrolysis is often used for producing high-purity hydrogen gas.

In alkaline electrolysis, the electrolyte solution is a basic one, typically made up of potassium hydroxide or sodium hydroxide. An ion-exchange membrane is used to separate the anode and cathode. Alkaline electrolysis is often used for producing hydrogen gas on a large scale, as it can operate at higher current densities and is less expensive than PEM electrolysis. However, the hydrogen gas produced by alkaline electrolysis is typical of lower purity than that produced by PEM electrolysis.

In economic terms; who is the winner? PEM or Alkaline

In terms of economics, alkaline electrolysis is generally considered to be more cost-effective than PEM electrolysis for producing hydrogen gas on a large scale. This is because alkaline electrolysis can operate at higher current densities, which allows for a higher rate of hydrogen production per unit of electrical energy. Additionally, the materials and equipment used in alkaline electrolysis are typically less expensive than those used in PEM electrolysis.

However, PEM electrolysis has some advantages over alkaline electrolysis in terms of the purity of the hydrogen gas produced. PEM electrolysis is capable of producing high-purity hydrogen gas (99.999%), which is often required for certain applications such as fuel cell vehicles. This higher purity comes at a cost, as PEM electrolysis requires more expensive materials and equipment, and the process is generally more energy-intensive than alkaline electrolysis.

Ultimately, the choice between PEM and alkaline electrolysis will depend on the specific application and the requirements for the hydrogen gas produced. If high-purity hydrogen is required, PEM electrolysis may be the better option, even though it may be more expensive. If lower-purity hydrogen is sufficient, alkaline electrolysis may be the more cost-effective choice.

For Hydrogen Production with Seawater; what is ideal for application? PEM or Alkaline Electrolyzers

Both PEM (Proton Exchange Membrane) electrolysis and alkaline electrolysis can be used to produce hydrogen gas from seawater. However, PEM electrolysis is generally considered to be more suitable for this application due to its ability to produce high-purity hydrogen gas and its ability to operate at lower temperatures.

Seawater contains a variety of dissolved ions, including sodium (Na+), chloride (Cl-), and magnesium (Mg2+). These ions can interfere with the electrolysis process and can cause corrosion of the electrolyzer components. PEM electrolysis is less sensitive to the presence of these ions, as the proton exchange membrane used in this process is less permeable to them. This allows PEM electrolysis to produce hydrogen gas with higher purity than alkaline electrolysis when using seawater as the feedstock.

In addition, PEM electrolysis can operate at lower temperatures than alkaline electrolysis, which can be an advantage in certain situations. For example, in warm climates where the seawater temperature is already high, using an electrolyzer that can operate at lower temperatures may be more energy-efficient.

Overall, PEM electrolysis may be a better option for producing hydrogen gas from seawater due to its ability to produce high-purity hydrogen gas and its ability to operate at lower temperatures. However, the specific choice between PEM and alkaline electrolysis will depend on the specific requirements and constraints of the application.

In terms of scaling up and application in GW scales; What is the ideal electrolyzer? PEM or Alkaline?

In terms of scalability, both PEM (Proton Exchange Membrane) electrolysis and alkaline electrolysis have the potential to be used at gigawatt scale. However, alkaline electrolysis is generally considered to be more suitable for large-scale hydrogen production due to its ability to operate at higher current densities and its lower cost compared to PEM electrolysis.

PEM electrolysis is typically more expensive and energy-intensive than alkaline electrolysis, which can be a disadvantage for large-scale hydrogen production. Additionally, PEM electrolysis is generally limited to producing hydrogen gas with a purity of 99.999%, which may not be necessary for some applications.

On the other hand, alkaline electrolysis can produce hydrogen gas with a lower purity, but it can do so at a lower cost and at higher current densities. This makes it more suitable for large-scale hydrogen production, particularly when the hydrogen gas does not need to be of the highest purity.

Overall, the choice between PEM and alkaline electrolysis for large-scale hydrogen production will depend on the specific requirements and constraints of the application. Alkaline electrolysis may be the more cost-effective option for producing hydrogen gas on a large scale, while PEM electrolysis may be more suitable for producing high-purity hydrogen gas.

Subscribe to Hydrogen Newsletter

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
[email protected]
Subscribe